News reports over the last few days say that Hillary Clinton has blamed her sleep deprivation for some statements she made which turned out to not be true. Unlike searching for a scientific paper and looking at the data, it is a lot harder to know exactly what happened when in situations like this. There are several available report and opinion articles available, but I did not see the actual initial “mis-statements” nor the blaming them on sleep deprivation. Here are several links to these articles.
The Independent. Minneapolis Star Tribune.PittsburghLive
Apparently during a recent speech at George Washington University she said that in 1996 she landed in Bosnia during sniper fire. Then, others who were with her on the trip basically proved in the following days that this was not at all true. She initially defended herself and then claimed that she must have said those things because she was “human” and “sleep-deprived.”
Can sleep deprivation make a person do this? Cause a person basically make false statements?
Before we answer this, let’s make sure we know what sleep deprivation is. In this case, I assume Mrs. Clinton is talking about not getting enough sleep in bed because she is too busy. I don’t think that she is talking about sleep deprivation from sleep disorders like sleep apnea; I don’t think that she is talking about being totally sleep deprived as is sometimes done during torture. I figure that she is talking about sleeping 5 or 6 hours a night; often less, sometimes more, during the busy campaign. (Actually, I’d like to hear from all of them—McCain, Obama, and Clinton—just how much sleep they need and how much they get. Maybe I’d vote for one of them based on the “sleep issue” but never mind that.)
So the answer depends on just how much sleep deprivation we are talking about. And if you just casually Google “sleep deprivation” to get the answer, it takes a lot of digging into the original studies to see what is really meant by sleep deprivation. The Wikipedia
lists about 22 symptoms of sleep deprivation, and “lying” is not one of them. However, there are 3 symptoms that could be important and result in a mis-statement. These are hallucinations, psychosis and memory lapses. However, psychosis and hallucinations usually occur only after very long and very complete sleep deprivation. I really hope that a possible future President is not prone to hallucinations, psychosis or memory lapses just because of her schedule.
In closing, I want to reassure those of you feel you don’t get enough sleep, either because of an insomnia problem or your busy schedule. More studies are needed to understand the relationship between sleep and physical disease. I suspect that the most dangerous effect of not sleeping enough is daytime sleepiness. Dozing off while driving is a real problem for people who are short on sleep, and are much more likely to harm you or others. So please, if you are tired or sleepy, get your sleep checked out. J. Steven Poceta MD
is a licensed practitioner of neurology and sleep disorders who has been engaged by Revolution Health. No information in this blog is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The opinions expressed here are Dr. Poceta’s own and do not necessarily reflect those of Revolution Health.